Guidelines for anaesthesiologist specialist training in pain medicine
European Journal of Anaesthesiology 2007; 24: 568–570
r 2007 Copyright European Society of Anaesthesiology
Guidelines for anaesthesiologist specialist training in pain medicineSECTION AND BOARD OF ANAESTHESIOLOGY1, European Union of Medical Specialists
Working party on Pain Medicine: A. J. Cunningham*, J. T. A. Knapey, H. Adriaensenz, W. P. Blunniez,E. Buchsery, Z. GoldikJ, W. Ilias**, V. Paver-Erzenyy
*Beaumont Hospital, Department of Anaesthesia, Beamont Road, Dublin, Ireland; yUniversity Medical CenterUtrecht, Division of Perioperative Care and Emergency Care, Department of Anaesthesiology, Utrecht, TheNetherlands; zUniversitair Ziekenhuis Antwerpen, Department of Anaesthesiology, Wilrijkstraat, Edegem, Belgium;
z Mater Hospital, Department of Anaesthesia and Intensive Care Medicine, Dublin, Ireland; yHoˆpital de Zone,
Service d’Anesthesiologie, Morges, Switzerland; JCarmel Medical Center, Department of Anesthesiology, Haifa, Israel;
**Krankenhaus der Barmherzige Bruder, Department of Anaesthesiology, Grosse Mohrengasse, Vienna, Austria;
y y University Medical Centre, Clinical Department of Anaesthesiology, Zaloska, Ljubljana, Slovenia
SummaryThe Section and Board of Anaesthesiology of the European Union of Medical Specialists aims (EUMS/UEMS)at harmonization of training of anaesthesiologists and at improvement of patient care throughout Europe. Painmedicine is considered to be an area of expertise in anaesthesiology although exclusivity is not claimed. TheSection and Board has approved both a core syllabus for pain medicine to be part of the specialist training inanaesthesiology and an additional qualification in pain medicine following the completion of a 5 yr basicspecialty training in anaesthesiology. These proposals were prepared by the Working Party on Pain Medicineof the Section and Board. It considers a multidisciplinary approach to pain to contribute to quality in care andhas taken the initiative to set up a Multidisciplinary Joint Committee on Pain Medicine within the EUMS/UEMS, for which these guidelines define the area of expertise of anaesthesiology.
Keywords: GUIDELINES; PAIN CLINICS; PAIN POSTOPERATIVE; EDUCATION; MEDICAL.
This document is divided into two sections and
Interest in postoperative pain management during the
incorporated in the European Union of Medical
1980s prompted the establishment of a new compo-
Specialists (EUMS/UEMS) Section and Board of
nent of anaesthesiology practice. A postoperative
analgesia or acute pain service may feature severalmodalities to combat postoperative pain. The basic
> Pain medicine in anaesthesia specialist training.
objectives of such services include administering and
> Additional qualification in pain medicine.
monitoring postoperative analgesia and identifying/managing complications or side-effects of postoperativeanalgesic techniques. Implicit in these objectives is the
inclusion of an active quality assurance programme
The areas of expertise of Anaesthesiology are: Perioperative Anaesthesia Care,
Emergency Medicine, Intensive Care Medicine, Pain Medicine and Reanimation
directed at maintaining high quality patient care.
Correspondence to: Johannes T. A. Knape, Department of Anaesthesiology,Division of Perioperative Care and Emergency Care, University Medical Center
Utrecht, P. O. Box 85500, 3508 GA Utrecht, The Netherlands. E-mail:[email protected]; Tel: 131302506716; Fax: 131302541828
Differentiation between acute and chronic pain is
Accepted for publication 23 December 2006
important in clinical practice because pathophysiology
and therapy may differ significantly. Pain persisting
Neuromodification techniques – central axial
longer than 6 months can be viewed as chronic pain.
Many departments of anaesthesia and individual
practitioners have organized pain clinics whosefunction is based on the use of nerve blocks for
the management of patients with difficult painproblems. The addition of psychological services,
Neurosurgical pain relieving procedures (basic
knowledge, indications, contra-indications and
detoxification) and physical therapy can markedly
increase the range of patients who can be success-
Psychological, psychiatric and behavioural inter-
fully managed in a nerve block clinic. The concept
of an interdisciplinary approach to cancer pain
management has recently been applied in manyinstitutions.
Postoperative pain (mechanisms, psychological
Section 1 – Guidelines for specialist training
effects, treatment modalities, acute pain service).
Diagnostic characteristics and treatment modal-
ities of musculoskeletal, visceral, ischaemic and
> Other systematic analgesics including adjuvants.
Headaches (migraine, tension headache, headache
from cervical origin, cluster headache, atypical
facial pain and trigemenial neuralgia).
Low back pain (anterior and posterior compart-
ment syndrome, radicular and pseudo-radicularsyndrome).
Neuropathic pain and pain syndromes (deaf-
> Central mechanisms for pain transmission.
ferentiation pain, phantom pain, sympathetic
reflex dystrophy, causalgia, neuromata, post-
herpetic neuralgia and central thalamic pain).
General principles of pain evaluation and manage-
Pharmacological treatment with opioids, NSAIDs,
drugs and other mixed agents (co-analgesics).
Indications and treatment possibilities using
> History taking and physical examination in
perispinal opioid administration systems.
patients suffering from postoperative, cancer and
Transcutaneous nerve simulation; indications and
> Pain measurement in man, basic concepts and
Indications and treatment modalities using
bias, scoring systems (visual analogue scales,
specific radiofrequency and neurolytic blockade
> Psychological aspects of pain (individual differ-
ences, socio-cultural influence, situational andenvironmental factors, the family and pain).
Case management and communication skills>
Show a relevant attitude towards patients suffer-ing from chronic pain.
Establish an acceptable contact with the patient
> Transcutaneous nerve simulation (indications and
Set up and maintain an acceptable contact with
> Perispinal opioid administration systems.
nurses, social workers, medical psychologists,
> Frequently used analgesic nerve blocks (diagnostic
psychiatrists, other consulting specialists and
r 2007 Copyright European Society of Anaesthesiology, European Journal of Anaesthesiology 24: 568–570
> Show abilities of self-confidence, knowledge of
Individual department heads should use the
his/her functioning and self criticism.
Inspectors’ report to strengthen their case with
management to ensure that acute and chronicpain facilities are provided.
Duration of pain medicine in anaestheticbasic specialist training
Section 2 – Additional qualification in painmedicine
specialist training should be on a continual basis
Refers to the concept of an add-on extra expertise
throughout the 5 yr of specialist training in
qualification following the completion of a 5 yr
basic specialty training in anaesthesia.
> The chronic pain medicine component could be
This concept relates to multidisciplinary practice
including neurology, neurosurgery, rehabilitation
medicine, orthopaedics, psychiatry and others.
mended and simulators, where available, would
Committee on Pain Medicine will develop thecurriculum/training/assessment and recognition
criteria for this add-on qualification.
> The role of log books or a portfolio in assessing
To determine the quality of additional training,
pain medicine, including chronic pain, in basic
consideration will be given to the content and
specialist training is confined to the trainee’s
duration of pain medicine experience in basic
ability to undertake practical procedures.
> The board recommends that a minimum 10% of
To acquire an add-on specialty qualification, an
the multiple-choice questions in the Diploma of
additional 2 yr pain medicine training may be
the European Academy of Anaesthesia (DEAA)
examination should relate to acute/chronic painmedicine and that these issues be systematicallyevaluated in the oral examinations.
The Multidisciplinary Joint Committee on Pain
Medicine will assess the curriculum to quantify
the time and the number of modules needed forspecialists to acquire the relevant knowledge,
In the Joint European Board of Anaesthesiology
clinical exposure and practical skills.
(EBA) EUMS–UEMS/European Society of Anaes-
The Multidisciplinary Joint Committee on Pain
thesiology (ESA) Hospital Visiting Programme,
Medicine will assess the role of log books and the
current assessment of acute and chronic pain is
role of an exit examination, including assessment
limited to the presence or absence of this exposure
of technical/communication skills and theoretical
The sub-committee recommendations included:
> The Joint EBA/ESA Hospital Inspection Team
should recommend that the Board’s Pain Medi-cine Training Guidelines be adhered to.
The Multidisciplinary Joint Committee on Pain
> Where these minimum training opportunities are
Medicine will determine how institutions can be
not available in certain institutions, trainees should
inspected to ensure they are suitable for training
be directed to acquire this training elsewhere.
specialists who aspire to this add-on qualification.
r 2007 Copyright European Society of Anaesthesiology, European Journal of Anaesthesiology 24: 568–570
Valley Bible Church – Sermon Transcript The Cleansing of the Temple John 2:14-17 On June 23, 2003, the NPR radio show "fresh air with Terry Gross" interviewed Dr. Samuel Barondes the author of a new book, Better than Prozac: Creating the Next Generation of Psychiatric Drugs. The book traces the history and analyzes the effectiveness of the current crop of antidepressants
3. Student Recruitment and Experience vi. Student Experience: Undergraduate, Graduate and International Student Survey Results Figure h-i Canadian Graduate and Professional Student Survey (CGPSS) Responses Performance Relevance: Graduate surveys like the CGPSS provide information that helps identify aspects of academic and student life that can be improved through changes